| Amazon.com
Reviews
Editorial Reviews
The publisher,
Jason Aronson Inc. , April 23, 1998
Torah and Dharma explores the phenomenon of Jews seeking spiritual
fulfillment in Eastern religions, particularly Buddhism. Through in-depth,
personal interviews of many "seekers," Dr. Judith Linzer exposes the similarities
and differences between the two traditions and gives an insightful interpretation
of the causes and consequences of such a religious journey.
Table
of Contents
Preface
Acknowledgments
Chapter One -- Introduction
Background of the Problem
Purpose of the Study
Statement of the Problem
Theoretical Framework
Methods of Research
Scope of the Study
Importance of the Study
Basic Assumptions/Presuppositions
Chapter Two -- Review of Literature
Hasidic Tale and Zen Koan
The Spiritual Path
The Modern Person Embarks on the Journey to the East
The Excursion Ends in Return
Jewish Identity
The Contemporary Jewish Renewal
Chapter Three -- Methods of Research
Typology
Interview Format
Chapter Four -- The Participants' Stories
Introduction
Summary of the Twelve Themes
Introduction to Background Information about Participants
The Newly Orthodox Jews (the Baalai Teshuvah)
Rachel
Nancy
Roberta
Mark
Dovid
Shmuel
Lorraine
Benjamin
Alan
Janet
Maurice
Karen
Joseph
The Formerly Orthodox Jews
Chaim
Barbara
Helen
Steven
Sharon
Ephraim
Warren
Introduction to the Theme of Jewish Identity
Perceived Internalized Anti-Semitism in Self or Others
Perceived Anti-Semitism
Lack of Knowledge of Judaism
Envious of Others' Self-Identity
Jewish Identity Influenced by a Grandparent
Positive Experiences with Judaism as a
Factor in Jewish Identity
"I Always Felt Jewish -- I Still Feel Jewish"
Going East and Finding Other Jews There Too
Eastern Teachers Tell Students to Explore Their Own Roots
The "Pintele Yid"
Ambivalent Attitude of Parents towards Being Jewish
Excursion and Return
Realizing that Spirituality Is "Real"
Realizing That Judaism Is a "Real" Spiritual Path
I Know I Can't Deny My Roots
Judaism Is Illuminated when Practicing the Eastern Religion
Translating the Language of Eastern
Religion into Judaism
The Practice of Eastern Religions Brings
Jewish Impulses to the Surface
The Formerly Orthodox Jews
Formerly Orthodox Jews Returning to Religious Judaism
Formerly Orthodox Expressed the Need to
Leave Religious Judaism
Chapter Five -- Summary, Conclusions, and
Implications
Summary
Conclusions
Implications for Further Research
Chapter Six -- Praises and Criticisms of Judaism and Eastern Religion
Jews Want Direct Spiritual Experience
What Needs to Happen within Judaism to Fix
It
It's "My" (the Baalai Teshuvah's) Responsibility to Bring This Knowledge
to
Other Jews and to Judaism -- The "Mission" of the Baal Teshuvah
Today's Practice of Judaism Is a Distortion of "the Real Thing"
Jews Like the Intensity and Commitment of Orthodoxy
Jews Like Parts of Judaism but Nothing Fits Quite Right
Orthodoxy Is Judgmental, Saying It Is the
Only Valid Form of Judaism
Judaism Isn't Presented Right
Jews Critical of Orthodox Upbringing
Jews Critical of Eastern Religion
Jews Praise the Eastern Religion
Jews Praise Judaism
Chapter Seven -- Updates
Introduction to Updates
Barbara's Update
Helen Harkaspi's Update
Ephraim's Update
Maurice Friedman's Update
Karen's Update
Lorraine's Update
Benjamin's Update
Dovid Zeller's Update
Judith Linzer's Update
Chapter Eight -- Jewish-Buddhist Encounter
Heresy Means Choice
Jerusalem and Benares
The Attitude One Brings to Interfaith
Dialogue
The Attitude One Has about One's Own Faith Tradition
Three Approaches to Religion: Orthodox,
Secular, and Liberal
The Main Difference between Jerusalem and Benares
How East and West See "The Other" as Problematic
Nihilation, or How Religions Invalidate Each Other
Constructive Use of the "Other" Religion to Gain Perspective
Jewish Questions, Buddhist Questions,
Christian Questions
Interfaith Dialogue as Family Therapy
What Is Mysticism and Who Needs It?
Mystical Nothingness in Judaism and Buddhism
Perspective versus Descriptive
The Horizontal and the Vertical
The Individual and the Collective
The Problem with Texts
Perhaps East and West Can Complement Each Other
Comparing Apples and Oranges
Normal Mysticism
Mystical Experience Invalidated within Western Religion
Core Content of Mystical Experience Is Similar across Religions
Conservative Seminary Out of Step with the
Mood of the 1960s
Psychedelic Drugs Provide Stimulus for
Mystical Experience
We Are Now Living in the Postmodern Age
The Task of the Postmodern, Multicultural
Age Is Interfaith Dialogue
Attachment versus Detachment
The Havdalah Problem
Women's Access to Jewish Mysticism and Textual Study Blocked by Sexism
Two Distinct Dialogues
Idolatry
Buddhism Helps Jews Cope with Our History of Suffering and Persecution
Do You Cast Your Lot with the Jewish People? And Who Wants to Know?
Reason to Feel Optimistic about the Future of Judaism
Blocked Access to Jewish Mysticism, or, Why
Judaism Hides Her Light
Jewish Continuity, or, What Is a Jew?
Bridge-Builders and Barrier-Builders
The Importance of the Hebrew Language
The Way Jews View History and Jewish Historical Perspective
Buddhist Historical Perspective and Mindset
The Post-Denominational Mystical Jew
In Defense of Halachah
So Many Buddhist Teachers and Leaders Are Jewish
The Wisdom that Jews Who Meditate Can Bring to Us
Drashot from Meditators' Points of View
What Does the Jewish Community Need?
The Future of Judaism, the Future of Buddhism
Epilogue
Notes
Glossary
References
Credits
Index |